MHRA – Breckenridge – Seroxat withdrawal problems

I’ve just read a piece at Seroxat Sufferers – Alasdair Breckenridge (head of the MHRA) is speaking about Seroxat, from The New Statesman in 2005.

It seems Breckenridge was happy that the MHRA had been up to speed on the Seroxat scandal from the very beginning: “If you go back – and I read this out to the Health Select Committee – to the data sheet on Seroxat when it was licensed in 1991, we spelt out word for word the problems of withdrawal from Seroxat, in words that we could not improve now. This idea that the regulators have been hiding the data is just not true. The so-called scandal of Seroxat is something I want to nail every time I speak in front of compatriots because it is absolute rubbish”.

And here is what Breckenridge actually said to the Health Select Committee: “…What the expert working group did was to look at three issues about antidepressants: firstly, the question of withdrawal; secondly, the question of suicidal ideation; and, thirdly, the question of dose. The problem of withdrawal has been well known with antidepressants, especially Seroxat, and I happen to have before me the information sheet, the data sheet which we published, which the MCA published in 1990 when Seroxat was first licensed. If I can just read it to you, it says, ‘As with many psychoactive medicines, it may be advisable to discontinue therapy gradually as abrupt discontinuation may lead to symptoms, such as dizziness, sensory disturbances, sleep disturbances, agitation or anxiety, nausea, sweating and confusion’. That was in 1990″.

I think the questions that arise are as follows: what exactly is a “data sheet” and how was it published and provided to patients in 1990? – because I can tell you that there was NO mention at all of withdrawal problems on the Patient Information Leaflet (PIL) that was provided in each box of Seroxat. Neither was there any advice to “discontinue therapy gradually”.

Also, given that the MCA (today’s MHRA) was aware that Seroxat caused withdrawal problems and one should “discontinue therapy gradually”, then please please tell me why there was no mention of these matters in the PIL. No one in their right mind could argue that the MCA had “nailed” the “so-called scandal of Seroxat”.

If the PIL did not inform patients about how to stop taking Seroxat and about the severity and frequency of withdrawal problems, then what did?


3 Responses to “MHRA – Breckenridge – Seroxat withdrawal problems”

  1. Matthew Holford Says:

    Anybody got Alasdair’s (that’s “D-A-I-R”) email address?


  2. truthman30 Says:

    I have seen the 1991 PIL and Breckenridge is talking through his holy hole . The 1991 Seroxat PIL is 2 very small pages worth of almost nothing. But if you compare the 2006 one and the 1996 one you will see massive changes and differences and if you could compare the 1991 also you would be amazed just how many side effects have been added ..

    (unfortunately the 1991 PIL is sensitive information though and no one has yet to reveal one)

    Either the MHRA were playing down the side effects of Seroxat themselves or the MHRA were given minimal data from GSK and made the PIL’s based on GSK’s biased submissions. Or maybe both were in collusion? Whatever the reasons, the PIL’s speak for themselves and both the MHRA and GSK have caused immeasureable suffering because of their disregard for patients. It seems to me that GSK and the MHRA have an unhealthy addiction to profit which has resulted in total disregard for the publics health. I don’t know of any pill that cures the rampant disease of “Greed”, but if there were , GSK and the MHRA could certainly need lifetime prescriptions…

  3. Matthew Holford Says:

    If my understanding is correct, the PILs are the responsibility of the manufacturer, although the regulator assesses and approves them. That’s nowadays (ie, since 1996). Back in 1991, I suspect that anything that went by the name of a PIL was solely a matter for the manufacturer, although it might be interesting to clarify that.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: